Medicare Advantage is a federal commission program with a $725 initial cap and a $363 renewal cap at the 2027 national rate, set by CMS and updated annually. Medicare Supplement is a state-regulated commission structure with no federal ceiling, percentage-based premiums, and renewal income that grows as the insured ages in attained-age-rated markets. The broker who understands these structures builds a book with intention. The one who does not often discovers the economic difference in year three, when their MA book generates less renewal income than expected and their Medigap referrals go to a competitor who made the comparison clearer at the start.
Key Takeaways
- CMS contract year 2027 Medicare Advantage initial compensation cap: $725 per enrollee at the national rate. Renewal cap: $363. Carriers may pay less but not more.
- Medicare Supplement commissions are not subject to CMS caps. State law and carrier contracts govern the rate, and the percentages vary by state and carrier.
- MA plans set their own payment schedule (monthly, quarterly or annual) but may only pay for the months a member is enrolled. If the member disenrolls, the plan recovers compensation for the months not enrolled.
- Attained-age-rated Medigap premiums rise as the insured ages, and all Medigap premiums can rise with inflation and other factors. A renewal percentage applied to a rising premium grows the dollar amount of renewal income without new enrollments.
- Under the NAIC Medigap model regulation, a replacement policy can pay no more than the replacing carrier's renewal compensation. Moving a Medigap client to a new carrier does not earn a new first year commission in states that follow it.
The CMS fair market value cap: what it covers and what it does not
CMS publishes fair market value (FMV) amounts each year in an agent and broker compensation memo to plan sponsors. The contract year 2027 memo, issued June 1, 2026, sets the national cap for an initial MA enrollment at $725 and the renewal cap at $363, with separate amounts for Connecticut, Pennsylvania and the District of Columbia ($816 and $408), California and New Jersey ($902 and $451), and Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands ($495 and $248). Commissions, bonuses, gifts, prizes and awards tied to the sale all count as compensation under 42 CFR 422.2274, so a carrier cannot use a bonus to pay above the cap. Payments for services other than enrollment, such as training or overhead paid to an FMO, are tested separately against the market value of those services.
The cap applies per enrollee per plan year, and the plan may only pay for months the member is enrolled. A client enrolled at AEP with a January 1 effective date is in the initial enrollment year for that calendar year. The renewal rate applies from the following January. Example: a client who stays enrolled for 5 years at the 2027 national rates would carry up to $725 in year one and up to $363 per year in years two through five, before any annual FMV updates.
See the Medicare broker compensation and CMS fair market value guide for the full framework of what counts toward the FMV cap, including non-cash compensation and administrative allowances.
| Factor | Medicare Advantage | Medicare Supplement |
|---|---|---|
| Regulatory authority | CMS (federal). Caps in 42 CFR 422.2274. | State insurance department. No federal cap. |
| 2027 initial commission | Up to $725 per member (national rate) | Carrier-specific percentage of first year premium |
| Renewal commission | Up to $363 per member per year (national rate) | Carrier-specific percentage of renewal premium; NAIC model keeps years 2 to 6 level |
| Commission structure | Plan sets monthly, quarterly or annual payment; paid only for months enrolled | Premium-based; continues while the policy is active and paid, per the carrier schedule |
| Effect of premium increases | CMS caps are dollar amounts; premium changes do not affect commission | Renewal commission % applied to higher premiums grows dollar income over time |
| Rate differences by plan | Allowed within the cap; plans report a rate or range of rates to CMS each July | Carriers can set different commission rates by plan |
| Client stickiness | Lower; Annual Enrollment Period allows plan switches without underwriting | Higher; outside open enrollment or a guaranteed issue right, a new carrier can underwrite |
Illustrative. CMS caps for 2027 are from the CMS agent and broker compensation memo (national rates). Medigap commission rates vary by state and carrier contract. Verify current carrier contracts before building revenue projections.
Medigap commission: state-regulated, percentage-based, and compounding
There is no CMS ceiling on Medigap broker commissions. Carriers set the percentages within state insurance law. The NAIC Medigap model regulation shapes the schedule rather than the rate: first year commission can be no more than 200 percent of the second year amount, renewal commission in later years must match the second year, and it must run for at least five renewal years. The same section caps compensation on a replacement policy at the replacing carrier's renewal rate. States adopt the model in their own words, so check your state's rule and each carrier's schedule for the actual percentages.
The percentage basis creates an income growth mechanism that MA does not have. To illustrate: assume a Plan G client at 65 pays $1,800 a year with an attained-age-rated carrier, and the premium reaches $2,700 by age 75. At an assumed 10 percent renewal rate, the broker's annual income from that single client grows from $180 to $270 without any new enrollment activity. An MA renewal on the same client is capped at the renewal FMV, $363 at the 2027 national rate, and moves only when CMS updates the FMV.
The trade-off is client retention. Outside the Medigap Open Enrollment Period, and without a guaranteed issue right, a carrier can use medical underwriting and may deny a policy. That creates natural stickiness: a client who has developed a new condition since their original Medigap enrollment may not be able to switch, which anchors them to the existing policy and the existing broker. MA clients can change plans every Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, with no underwriting, which tends to produce more churn in MA books than in Medigap books.
D-SNP commissions: the third structure in the Medicare broker toolkit
Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs) are a subtype of Medicare Advantage and follow the same CMS FMV cap structure. Initial D-SNP compensation is capped at $725 for 2027 at the national rate, and renewals at $363. The commission structure is identical to standard MA.
The difference is in the client population and the enrollment pattern. D-SNP clients are dual eligibles who may lose Medicaid and require plan transitions mid-year, which creates a higher volume of enrollment transactions per client than a standard MA client who changes plans only during AEP. More transactions do not mean more initial commissions. Under 42 CFR 422.2274, a plan change during the initial enrollment year is paid as pro-rated initial compensation, and a later move from one MA plan to another is a like plan type change paid at the renewal rate. What D-SNP churn adds is reconciliation work.
The D-SNP enrollment and broker compensation guide covers how initial vs renewal compensation applies across the different D-SNP plan types and what happens to commission when a D-SNP client loses Medicaid eligibility.
Building a revenue projection: MA book vs Medigap book vs mixed book
The economic comparison between an MA-heavy and a Medigap-heavy practice comes down to enrollment volume, client retention, and premium trajectory. Neither book is strictly superior; the right mix depends on the broker's local market, their client demographics, and whether they prefer predictable capped income or variable percentage income that scales with premium.
Example: an MA-heavy practice with 300 active enrollees paid at the 2027 national renewal cap would carry up to $108,900 in annual MA renewal income at 100 percent retention. At an assumed 85 to 90 percent retention, that is $92,565 to $98,010. New enrollments each year add initial compensation of up to $725 per new member.
A Medigap-heavy practice with 300 active policyholders at an assumed average annual premium of $2,200 and an assumed 10 percent renewal rate generates $66,000 in annual renewal income. If the book churns less than an MA book and premiums rise as it ages, a Medigap book's renewal income can grow without proportional new enrollment activity. AgencyBloc advertises commission tracking on its public site (checked July 2026); any tool like that needs accurate commission percentages entered to produce a useful forecast. In the QuoteTurbo Medicare CRM, a Med Supp policy is recorded by its Medigap plan letter and an MA or Part D policy by its CMS plan ID, so the mix of the two in a book sits on the policy records.
Example: a 5-year projection for a broker adding 50 new Medicare clients per year.
Illustrative example. Actual commission income depends on state-specific rates, carrier contracts, enrollment retention, premium levels, and annual CMS cap adjustments. These figures should not be used as a basis for financial planning without verifying current carrier commission schedules.
| Year | MA-only book (50 new/yr, $725 initial, $363 renewal, 88% retention) | Medigap-only book (50 new/yr, assumed 20% yr1 and 10% renewal, $2,200 avg premium held flat, 93% retention) |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $36,250 (50 initial) | $22,000 (50 at 20% of $2,200) |
| Year 2 | $52,222 (50 new initial + 44 renewals) | $32,340 (50 new first year + 47 at 10%) |
| Year 3 | $66,379 (50 new initial + 83 renewals) | $41,800 (50 new first year + 90 at 10%) |
| Year 5 | $89,611 (50 new initial + 147 renewals) | $58,740 (50 new first year + 167 at 10%) |
Illustrative projections only, at 2027 national MA rates with retained members rounded to whole clients each year. Actual commissions depend on carrier schedules, state law, retention and premiums. MA income benefits from higher initial commission and larger total book volume faster. Medigap income grows more slowly but is less sensitive to disenrollment if clients cannot switch carriers without underwriting.
MA vs Medigap commission structure: broker FAQ
The compensation questions Medicare brokers ask when comparing their MA and Medigap books.
What is the CMS fair market value cap for Medicare Advantage commissions in 2027?
How do Medicare Advantage and Medigap renewal commissions compare over a 5-year book?
Can a Medicare Advantage carrier pay a higher initial commission for enrolling clients in a richer plan?
What happens to Medicare Advantage commissions when a client disenrolls or switches plans?
How does the Medicare Supplement commission structure differ between attained-age, issue-age, and community-rated plans?
Sources
- Contract Year 2027 Agent and Broker Compensation Rates, Referral/Finder's Fees, Submissions, and Training and Testing Requirements (memo copy hosted by NAIFA), CMS
- 42 CFR 422.2274: Agent, broker, and other third-party requirements, eCFR
- Model Regulation to Implement the NAIC Medicare Supplement Insurance Minimum Standards Model Act, NAIC
- Choosing a Medigap Policy: A Guide to Health Insurance for People with Medicare, Medicare.gov
- Joining a plan, Medicare.gov