Cost per sale is the lead spend it took to write one policy. Take what a vendor billed you for the month and divide it by the sales that came from that vendor's leads. To illustrate: a $30 lead that turns into a sale once in 25 leads costs $750 per sale. A $75 transfer that turns into a sale once in 5 transfers costs $375. The cheaper lead lost.

The lead cost per sale calculatorbelow runs that math for up to four vendors at once, priced per lead or per live transfer. Enter last month's numbers, not the ones on the vendor's rate card. Add the average annual premium and your commission rate and it also shows commission per sale and how many dollars of commission each dollar of lead spend brought back.

Up to 4 vendors

Compare lead vendors by cost per sale

The starting numbers are examples, not industry averages. Replace them with your own from last month. Close rate means the share of contacted leads that bought, not the share of every lead you paid for. Results update as you type.

Vendor A
Priced per

Share of leads an agent actually talks to

Share of contacts that buy

First year commission as a share of annual premium

Vendor B
Priced per

Share of transfers an agent actually talks to

Share of contacts that buy

First year commission as a share of annual premium

Results

Vendor B has the lowest cost per sale at $417.

Cost per contact, cost per sale, and return on lead spend for each vendor
MetricVendor AVendor B
Monthly lead spend$9,000$9,000
Contacts per month120108
Cost per contact$75.00$83.33
Sales per month1221.6
Cost per sale$750$417Lowest
Commission per saleNeeds premium and commission raten/an/a
Return on lead spendCommission per $1 of lead spendn/an/a
Commission minus lead spendPer monthn/an/a

Figures are illustrative and only as good as the numbers you enter. Commission per sale is first year commission before chargebacks. Actual lead prices, contact rates, close rates, and commissions vary by vendor, line of business, and agency. Not financial or insurance advice.

Key Takeaways

  • Cost per sale is monthly lead spend divided by sales from that vendor.
  • Close rate here means the share of contacted leads that bought, not the share of every lead bought.
  • A cheaper lead with a low contact rate can cost more per sale than a pricier live transfer.
  • Return on lead spend above 1.00x means commission beat lead spend, before agent pay and chargebacks.
  • Rerun the numbers each month. Vendor pricing and contact rates can move between summer and open enrollment.

How the math works

Seven formulas, run left to right. Contact rate and close rate are entered as percentages and used as fractions, so 40% becomes 0.40. When a vendor produces no contacts or no sales, the per unit cost shows as empty instead of dividing by zero.

Monthly lead spend
= cost per lead × leads bought per month
Contacts per month
= leads bought per month × contact rate
Cost per contact
= monthly lead spend ÷ contacts per month
Sales per month
= contacts per month × close rate
Cost per sale
= monthly lead spend ÷ sales per month
Commission per sale
= average annual premium × commission rate
Return on lead spend
= (commission per sale × sales per month) ÷ monthly lead spend

Commission per sale uses first year commission only. If your contract pays renewals, the lifetime value of a sale is higher. If the carrier charges back on early cancellations, the real first year number is lower. The calculator does not guess either way.

Example: two vendors on the same budget

Example: an agency spends $9,000 a month with each of two vendors, and the average sale carries $1,500 in annual premium at a 50% first year commission, so $750 per sale. These figures are illustrative, not market rates.

Vendor A sells leads at $30 each. The agency buys 300 of them, reaches 40%, and closes 10% of the people it reaches. That is 120 contacts at $75 each and 12 sales at $750 each. Commission comes to $9,000, which is exactly the lead spend. Return on lead spend: 1.00x. The vendor paid for itself and nothing else.

Vendor B sells live transfers at $75 each. The agency buys 120, talks to 90% of them, and closes 20% of those conversations. That is 108 contacts at about $83 each and 21.6 sales at about $417 each. Commission comes to $16,200 against the same $9,000. Return on lead spend: 1.80x.

Illustrative example. Actual lead prices, contact rates, close rates, premiums, and commissions vary by vendor, line of business, state, and agency.

The pattern: Vendor A was cheaper per contact and still lost on cost per sale. The price on the invoice sorts vendors one way. Close rate sorts them the way the commission statement does.

Why price per lead is the wrong ranking

Every vendor quotes a price per lead because that is the number they control. Contact rate and close rate are the numbers you control, and they decide everything after the invoice. A floor that ranks vendors by price per lead can end up buying more of the leads its agents cannot reach.

Contact rate is also where most of the arguing happens. A lead that was sold to several buyers tends to show up in your numbers as a lower contact rate, not as a line on the rate card. So will bad phone numbers and leads that were already called by someone else that morning. Cost per contact catches that before cost per sale does.

What this calculator does not see

It does not know what you pay your agents, what the dialer and phone minutes cost, or how many leads the vendor credited back. It does not model cancellations, chargebacks, or renewals. It assumes every sale carries the average premium you entered, which is never quite true. Treat the return figure as the most a vendor could be worth, then subtract what you know.

It also only sees one month. During AEP and OEP the same vendor can look very different from its July self, because volume, pricing, and how hard your agents work each lead all shift. Run it with November numbers in November.

FAQ

What is a good cost per sale for insurance leads?
There is no single good number, and this page does not publish one. A cost per sale is good when it sits below what the sale pays you. Enter the average annual premium and your commission rate: a return on lead spend above 1.00x means the vendor's leads paid back more commission than they cost, before agent pay and chargebacks.
Is close rate a share of all leads or of contacted leads?
Of contacted leads. The calculator multiplies leads by contact rate first, then by close rate. If your report gives close rate across every lead bought, enter 100% as the contact rate and that figure as the close rate. The cost per sale comes out the same.
How do I compare a live transfer vendor with a per lead vendor?
Add both and set one to live transfer. A transfer arrives with the consumer already on the line, so its contact rate is the share of transfers where your agent actually talked to someone before the line dropped. Cost per sale puts both pricing models on the same footing.
Does return on lead spend include agent pay or chargebacks?
No. It divides first year commission by lead spend and nothing else. Agent pay, dialer and phone costs, returned leads, cancellations and chargebacks all come out of the same commission, so treat the figure as a ceiling, not a profit number.
My carrier pays a flat amount per member per month. What do I enter?
Multiply the monthly amount by 12 and by the members on a typical policy, enter that as the average annual premium, and set the commission rate to 100%. Commission per sale then equals one year of flat payments.
Can QuoteTurbo track cost per sale by vendor for me?
Yes. Each vendor page in the CRM shows spend for today, 7 days and 30 days, the calls that did not bill, and the cost per sale. Billing is worked out on the server from the vendor's billing rule, and the vendor results report puts vendors side by side.

For how vendor leads land in the CRM, route to licensed agents, and bill, see insurance lead management. For the dialer side of working those leads, see the insurance dialer. For running a floor through open enrollment, read the call center playbook for ACA selling.

Figures shown are illustrative and depend on the numbers you enter. Actual lead costs, contact rates, close rates, premiums, and commissions vary by vendor, line of business, and agency. Not insurance, tax, or financial advice.

QuoteTurbo is a software tool. It does not provide insurance advice. Coverage decisions rest with the broker and the consumer.